The Iliad

536795_Homer_The Iliad.indd

The Iliad – Homer

Yesterday I posted about The Iliad‘s sort-of-sequel, The Odyssey, so really, these posts are in the wrong order. I wrote about The Odyssey because I wanted to challenge the notion that it is dull and difficult to read, which made sense because it is generally considered to be the more accessible of the two, however it got me thinking and I decided that The Iliad deserved the same treatment, not least because I actually preferred The Iliad.

In a sense, I’m very mainstream in my literary tastes- I rarely like something that everyone else hates- and so when my lecturer mentioned that students tend to prefer the ‘easier’ Odyssey, I assumed that I would follow the same pattern, but I ended up bucking the trend. The Iliad is more difficult to read than The Odyssey but it’s also much more rewarding; it’s more complex, more ambiguous, more varied in its characters and a much more moving piece of literature.

The Iliad covers an eventful few weeks during the final year of the Trojan War (although it jumps around a lot and much backstory and legend is related, as is the way with epics) and presents the reader with viewpoints from the Greek and Trojan side. It covers disputes within the Greek army, as well as the petty battling among the gods, and, unlike The Odyssey, things are most certainly not in black and white. It’s not so much a case of picking a side as it is of watching helplessly as two characters you find yourself rooting for battle each other to the death. War in The Iliad isn’t right versus wrong but man versus man, and victory and tragedy become one and the same. Although the text was written thousands of years ago and includes much myth and legend, its presentation of war still rings true and is perhaps more pertinent today than ever.

The Iliad is, in short, an astounding piece of literature. The legends are drawn together so seamlessly and the narrative moves so fluidly back and forth in time that one can only speculate that this must have taken months, perhaps even years, to plan. There are many long and tedious battle scenes, but in between that there are stories of love and loyalty and a very touching familial scene between Hector and his family. It can also be difficult to keep track of who’s who if you don’t know much about Greek legend (which I didn’t) but you get the hang of it after a while, and the varied cast of characters and their tangled lives certainly keeps it interesting- sometimes it feels more like a soap opera than an epic Greek poem! The most difficult (and deathly boring) part of The Iliad is definitely the epic lists, such as the Catalogue of Ships in Book II (not gonna lie, I just skipped it). The epithets can also be distracting and a little repetitive (they were a poetic convention but they just seem redundant and often annoying today) but you get used to them.

So to sum it up, The Iliad is more complex and much less familiar in form than The Odyssey, but it is also a much more gratifying piece of literature. You learn more about Greek myth and legend, experience an interesting portrayal of humanity and war and learn more about the disputes and petty jealousies of the gods. It’s not an easy read, but remember that easy doesn’t equate to good, and it’s nowhere near as difficult or boring as I thought it would be. It’s still literature that you can sink your teeth into, and if you take it Book by Book then you’ll have it finished in no time!

Currently reading…

Image

Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides

This is just a quick post about what I’m currently reading! Some of you may know Eugenides because he has won the Pulitzer Prize, others because of his other successful novel, The Virgin Suicides, which I confess I haven’t read. It’s a tale of a hermaphrodite named Cal (formerly Callie) but, in the tradition of the Greek epic, it’s not just Cal’s story. It begins with the tale of Desdemona and Lefty Stephanides, Cal’s grandparents, in order to explain why Cal is the way he is. But Desdemona and Lefty aren’t just husband and wife- they’re also brother and sister. If you don’t think of Desdemona and Lefty as brother and sister then their story is very sweet but because they are siblings their relationship is fairly difficult to grasp. How can brothers and sisters be attracted to each other? But that’s the beauty of literature- it pushes the boundaries and forces you to consider things that you normally wouldn’t think about, or perhaps avoid thinking about. 

Causation is a major theme within the novel. It is somewhat a re-invention of an epic, a hybrid of Greek and American. Cal often mentions going back to the beginning of things- stories, rivers, production lines. I really like this aspect of the book as it makes me wonder about when a story truly begins. You could trace it back to the beginning of time, I suppose. Really a ‘story’ is not a complete thing, it’s just a snapshot. Cal, however, is trying to provide us with more than that, perhaps because he wants to understand himself and to do that you have to go right back to the beginning.

Anyway that’s all from me tonight. Please let me know what you’re currently reading; I’m always interested! 

30 day book challenge; day 16, the longest book you’ve read

Image

Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell.

This book is truly epic. It may be 1011 pages long but it certainly doesn’t feel like that- yes, it does capture ten years of Scarlett O’Hara’s life but it is also incredibly absorbing and you won’t want it to end. It depicts the extent to which war can change a nation and also a person. Scarlett starts off as shallow, selfish and manipulative but by the end of the book she is incredibly hardened, but also (in my opinion) a much more likeable character. You can’t fail to respect her strength and the way in which she works tirelessly to provide for her family. At the start of the book she was a largely unlikeable teenage girl but by the end of the book she is a flawed yet very admirable character. This book really is about change and its length doesn’t feel excessive, so don’t let it put you off!

What’s the longest book YOU’ve read? Let me know in a comment!